

Your founders, board members, and long-time donors know people who would care about your mission. Some of those people could become your next donors. But asking a friend or peer to give for the first time feels awkward, and many supporters don't know where to start, so they never ask.
At Kindest, we work with executive directors, development teams, and board members on exactly this. The three steps below are the ones we give supporters to make it easier to bring in their networks.
You aren't asking for donations to yourself. You're asking people to support the mission. When you bring in your network, you help the nonprofit make a greater impact, and that's the conversation to keep in mind as you reach out.
With that in mind, here's how we recommend making the ask.
When you move from friend or peer to donor, give people a heads up before you make the pitch. Asking straight away is awkward and rarely works. The first step is simply letting people know you'd like to share more about your work and your mission.
Example: "I rarely talk about my philanthropy. I'd like to share more with you about my work."
Once people know what to expect, the next step is a lightweight ask that involves education, not giving. They've only just learned about your mission and aren't ready to give.
This step can take several conversations, emails, texts, and events, with words from different trusted allies and from people your organization has helped.
Example: "Here's how the organization has helped our community. Learn more in this article."
Now that people have had a heads up and a chance to learn, they are ready for the ask. Keep it personal and specific. It should come from someone they know, say what the gift will do, and link to an easy place to give. Consider inviting allies, or people your organization has helped, to add their own voices.
Example: "I hope you will give serious consideration to supporting such a worthy cause."
When you invite first-time donors from your network, the channel matters as much as the message. Base it on your existing relationship and where the person is in your sequence. Start with two questions:
A close friend may prefer a call or text first, while someone you rarely see may be more comfortable with an email.
Different people should hear different things, based on your relationship with them and how they've responded to what you've already shared. For each person, ask:
Use the answers to decide who gets a personal note, who gets the email sequence, and who is left out of the ask entirely, such as people who have already given.
Before you send anything, ask yourself:
If your program has outgrown the generosity of a few people, we'd love to help. At Kindest Consulting, we help you craft and execute a strategy that feels true to you and fits your team.

